NashVillager Podcast: County vs. State

Who has the right to send in the troops in Tennessee?

As Shelby County sues the governor for potentially overstepping his role, a look at the state laws that are cited in the court case. Plus, the local news for October 21, 2025, and the race to save an endangered Tennessee fish. 

Credits:

This is a production of Nashville Public Radio
Host/producer: Nina Cardona
Editor: Miriam Kramer
Additional support: Tony Gonzalez, Mack Linebaugh, LaTonya Turner and the staff of WPLN and WNXP

The lawsuit filed in October 2025

On Oct. 17, 2025, Shelby County Mayor Lee Harris and other local elected officials sued Gov. Bill Lee in Davidson County Chancery Court over the deployment of Tennessee National Guard troops to Memphis. The complaint, prepared with the nonprofit Democracy Forward, names Lee, Attorney General Skrmetti and Maj. Gen. Warner Ross III as defendants.

The complaint argues that the deployment violates the Tennessee Constitution and state statutes. It says state law requires a city or county government to formally request Guard support for a breakdown of law and order, and that Memphis and Shelby County never made that request. It also says a statewide deployment needs legislative advice and consent, which the governor did not seek. Plaintiffs point to the state constitution's limit on Guard use to circumstances “amounting to a rebellion or invasion.”

The state's position

The governor's office has said that, as commander-in-chief, the governor has authority to order the Guard mission to Memphis, which supports the Memphis Safe Task Force. At a November hearing, the state argued that the governor has sole authority to mobilize the troops. Gov. Lee's office said it was confident the courts would uphold the governor's constitutional authority.

How the case has moved

In November 2025, Davidson County Chancellor Patricia Head Moskal found that the plaintiffs were likely to succeed and issued a temporary injunction. Reporting on the order said that supporting public safety and law enforcement is not among the emergency conditions that state law lists for the governor to call up troops. The order was paused so the state could appeal, and the deployment continued while the appeal was pending.

In April 2026 the Tennessee Court of Appeals reversed the injunction. It ruled that the plaintiffs, including Harris, did not have legal standing to bring the case. Whether the case went further, to the Tennessee Supreme Court, has not been reported.

Update, Nov. 13: The April 2026 reversal lifted the injunction, so the Guard deployment is no longer blocked by that order. No later ruling has been reported, so the status after April 2026 has not been confirmed.

Author

  • Welcome to Nashvegas.com. This site was designed to help foster communication between the residents of Nashville, Tennessee. Whether you're looking for news, events, jobs, etc. you can find it all right here on Nashvegas.com.

Nashvegas.com

Welcome to Nashvegas.com. This site was designed to help foster communication between the residents of Nashville, Tennessee. Whether you're looking for news, events, jobs, etc. you can find it all right here on Nashvegas.com.

Related Articles

Back to top button