Top 10 Pizza Restaurants in Nashville

Nashville may still get most of its food headlines for hot chicken and meat-and-three classics, but locals know the pizza scene has gotten seriously deep. Whether you want a giant New York-style fold, a blistered neo-Neapolitan pie, a square Sicilian slice, or a proper tavern-style crunch, Music City now has options all over town.

For this list, we prioritized recent Yelp star ratings, total review count, category relevance, and the kind of local buzz that keeps a place packed long after the first hype wave passes. In plain English: we were looking for pizza spots that people actually return to, recommend to friends, and work into their regular Nashville rotation.

If you’re trying to figure out where to grab a late-night slice after Broadway, where to take family in West Nashville, or where to impress the friend who treats pizza like a personality trait, this list should save you a few bad guesses.

The List

1. Five Points Pizza

• Yelp Rating: 4.5
• Number of Reviews: 1.7k
• Business Category: Italian / Pizza
• City: Nashville
• Website URL: https://fivepointspizza.com/

Five Points Pizza has become one of the city’s most dependable pizza institutions, and the review volume backs that up. This is the kind of place that shows up again and again in “where should we go tonight?” group texts because it hits that sweet spot between casual neighborhood hang and genuinely memorable pizza.

What makes it stand out is the New York-style identity. Big foldable slices, thin crust, garlic knots, cold beer, and an easygoing room make it feel just as useful for a quick lunch as it is for a full-on weekend dinner.

Why Locals Love It: It feels like a Nashville staple now. East Nashville regulars swear by it, visitors hear about it fast, and it remains one of the safest bets in town when you need a pizza place that almost everyone in the car will agree on.

2. Tutti Da Gio

• Yelp Rating: 4.6
• Number of Reviews: 254
• Business Category: Sicilian / Pizza
• City: Hermitage
• Website URL: https://www.tuttidagio.com/hermitage

Tutti Da Gio earns a high spot because it pairs an excellent Yelp rating with a strong review count and a style that stands out in the Nashville area. This isn’t trying to be an all-things-to-all-people pizza stop. It leans into Sicilian roots and gives diners something a little more distinctive than the usual slice shop formula.

The restaurant feels like a great answer for anyone who wants pizza with a little more personality. Thick, satisfying, richly flavored pies and a broader Italian sensibility help it rise above the usual quick-slice lane.

Why Locals Love It: It gives Hermitage and the broader east side of Davidson County a destination-level pizza option. Folks who find it tend to come back with the energy of people who can’t believe more of Nashville isn’t talking about it yet.

3. Sho Pizza Bar

• Yelp Rating: 4.6
• Number of Reviews: 132
• Business Category: Pizza
• City: Nashville
• Website URL: https://www.shopizzabar.com/

Sho Pizza Bar feels like one of the clearest signals that Nashville’s pizza scene has grown up. The concept is focused, stylish, and very deliberate, with a neo-Neapolitan approach that gives the whole place a little more edge than your average pizza night spot.

The big draw here is craft. From the wood-fired oven to the chef’s-counter view, the experience feels built for people who really want to pay attention to what lands on the table. It manages to feel polished without becoming stiff.

Why Locals Love It: East Nashville diners tend to reward places that feel specific instead of generic, and Sho absolutely fits that mold. It is the kind of restaurant people mention when they want to prove Nashville can do more than comfort food greatest hits.

4. Five Points Pizza – West Nashville

• Yelp Rating: 4.5
• Number of Reviews: 298
• Business Category: Pizza
• City: Nashville
• Website URL: https://fivepointspizza.com/west-nashville/

The West Nashville outpost takes everything people already like about Five Points and makes it easier for Charlotte Avenue and Sylvan Park pizza runs. It has enough reviews on its own to prove this is not just coasting on the original location’s reputation.

You still get that classic New York-style lane, but the west side location is especially handy for families, takeout nights, and laid-back group dinners where nobody wants a complicated menu.

Why Locals Love It: West Nashville residents love not having to cross town for a dependable pie. It is familiar, consistent, and exactly the kind of place that becomes part of a household routine.

5. Midnight Oil

• Yelp Rating: 4.5
• Number of Reviews: 153
• Business Category: Pizza
• City: Nashville
• Website URL: https://midnightoilpizza.com

Midnight Oil has built a loyal following by keeping the pitch simple: great New York-style pizza in a casual, social setting. The Nations location especially has become a strong neighborhood player, and the review score suggests it is doing more than just catching spillover traffic from a busy area.

There is a fun, easygoing energy to the brand that works well for Nashville. It feels just as suited for game-day hangs and beer-with-friends nights as it does for a straightforward slice craving.

Why Locals Love It: It feels built for repeat visits. Nashville has plenty of places that are cool once. Midnight Oil feels like somewhere you actually keep returning to.

6. NY Pie

• Yelp Rating: 4.4
• Number of Reviews: 373
• Business Category: Pizza
• City: Nashville
• Website URL: https://www.nypienashville.com/

NY Pie holds its place in this ranking because of its combination of strong review volume and steady reputation. For a lot of west-side pizza fans, it has been a reliable go-to for years, and that kind of staying power matters when building a list like this.

Its identity is right there in the name: New York pizza with Nashville soul. That makes it an easy recommendation for anyone chasing a classic thin-crust pie without giving up the comfort and friendliness locals expect from neighborhood dining.

Why Locals Love It: This is the sort of restaurant people recommend with conviction. Not because it is flashy, but because it has delivered consistently enough to earn a lot of trust around town.

7. St. Vito Focacceria

• Yelp Rating: 4.5
• Number of Reviews: 110
• Business Category: Pizza / Sicilian
• City: Nashville
• Website URL: https://www.stvitonashville.com/

St. Vito Focacceria brings a different kind of pizza conversation to Nashville. The menu is rooted in Sicilian style, the kitchen emphasizes scratch-made cooking and local produce, and the whole experience feels more chef-driven than the typical weeknight pizza stop.

This is a strong pick when you want pizza that still feels dinner-worthy. It is rich, distinctive, and a little more intentional, which makes it ideal for date nights or for out-of-town guests who think pizza has to be casual to be good.

Why Locals Love It: It feels like one of those modern Nashville restaurants that still has soul. You go for the pizza, but the thoughtfulness of the whole meal is what tends to stick with people.

8. Two Boots Nashville

• Yelp Rating: 4.0
• Number of Reviews: 548
• Business Category: Pizza
• City: Nashville
• Website URL: https://twoboots.com/locations/

Two Boots lands in the top 10 because the review count is hard to ignore, and it has become a familiar option for Midtown and Broadway-area pizza seekers. The concept blends Italian and Cajun influences, which gives it a more playful personality than a standard slice counter.

If you want a pizza place with color, attitude, and a late-night-friendly location, this one makes a lot of sense. It is especially practical when you want something fast, flavorful, and right in the middle of the action.

Why Locals Love It: It works. That matters. Not every pizza night needs to be a culinary thesis. Sometimes you want a slice near the center of town that is dependable and easy to recommend to visitors.

9. Dicey’s Pizza & Tavern

• Yelp Rating: 4.0
• Number of Reviews: 320
• Business Category: Pizza / Beer Bar
• City: Nashville
• Website URL: https://www.diceystavern.com/

Dicey’s has carved out a lane by leaning into tavern-style pizza rather than chasing whatever trend is hottest this month. That gives the place a real identity, and in a city with a growing number of pizza concepts, identity goes a long way.

Located in Wedgewood-Houston, it fits the neighborhood well: casual, stylish, a little buzzy, but still grounded in food people actually want to order again. It is a smart choice when your group wants something crunchy, sharable, and beer-friendly.

Why Locals Love It: Dicey’s feels like a neighborhood spot with taste. It is the kind of place Nashville residents bring up when they want something that feels current without being overdone.

10. DeSano Pizzeria Napoletana

• Yelp Rating: 3.9
• Number of Reviews: 89
• Business Category: Pizza
• City: Nashville
• Website URL: https://desanopizza.com/desanonashville

DeSano rounds out the list thanks to its recognizable Neapolitan identity and its place in the broader Nashville pizza conversation. Even with a lower Yelp score than others here, it still brings a very specific style to the table, and that relevance counts in a city where diners want more than one kind of pie.

This is the place to consider when you want a softer, more traditional Neapolitan approach rather than a giant foldable slice or a cracker-thin tavern crust. It fills an important lane on the map.

Why Locals Love It: Nashville pizza fans appreciate having options, and DeSano keeps the Neapolitan side of the scene in the mix. For the right style preference, it scratches an itch that other spots on this list are not trying to hit.

FAQ

What is the highest-rated pizza restaurant in Nashville, TN on this list?

• Based on the Yelp data used for this article, Sho Pizza Bar and Tutti Da Gio both posted 4.6-star Yelp ratings, with Tutti Da Gio carrying the larger review count of the two.

Are these Nashville pizza rankings based on Yelp reviews?

• Yes. The rankings are primarily based on publicly available Yelp star ratings and review volume, with local popularity, category relevance, and consistency used as editorial tie-breakers.

Where can I get New York-style pizza in Nashville?

• Five Points Pizza, Five Points Pizza – West Nashville, Midnight Oil, and NY Pie are all strong picks if you are looking for a New York-style pizza experience in the Nashville area.

What is a good Sicilian pizza spot near Nashville?

• St. Vito Focacceria and Tutti Da Gio are two of the strongest Sicilian-style options in this roundup, each bringing a more distinctive square-pie approach than a typical slice shop.

Which Nashville pizza spots are best for locals and repeat visits?

• Five Points Pizza, NY Pie, Midnight Oil, and Dicey’s all feel especially repeatable because they combine neighborhood convenience, strong review profiles, and styles that work for casual weeknight dinners as well as group hangouts.

Nashville’s pizza scene is in a very good place right now. You can keep it classic with a foldable New York slice, go chef-driven with neo-Neapolitan or Sicilian pies, or lean tavern-style when the mood calls for something crisp and sharable. The best part is that these aren’t one-off novelty stops. They are the kinds of restaurants that help shape how people actually eat around town.

If you’ve been meaning to branch out beyond your usual order, this list is a pretty good excuse to make it happen. Try a new spot, support a local pizza shop, share this article with the friend who always claims to know the best slice in town, and drop your own Nashville favorite in the comments.

Disclaimer: Rankings are based on publicly available Yelp ratings, review volume, and local popularity at the time of publication.