Rutherford County Library Board makes list of candidates for interim director position
The board ousted James after she refused to move 190 books — many of which had LGBTQ themes or characters — from the children’s section to the adult section.
Background: the March 2026 board vote
The Rutherford County Library Board voted on March 16, 2026 to relocate certain books from children's sections to adult sections in county libraries. Two days later, director Luanne James told the board by email that she would not carry out the move, according to reporting on the dispute. On March 30, 2026, the board voted 8-3 to end her employment. The board's stated reason for the change was “age-appropriateness,” and some outlets described the books as having LGBTQ-themed content. The reported number of books varies by source: WSMV's September 2026 report cites 132 children's books, while other reports cite more than 100 or 190.
James has said that moving the books would violate First Amendment protections and her professional obligations, and her attorney has called the firing unlawful. Board Chair Cody York has denied wrongdoing in response to a separate allegation by James that he sought lists of patrons who borrowed LGBTQ-themed books. PEN America's Freedom to Read program condemned the firing, according to its statement reported in the coverage.
The interim appointment and the permanent search
Reporting on the search said the board called four internal employees in turn, and that the first to accept would take the interim role. The Rutherford County Library System's own announcement names David Coutcher, the system's Human Resources and Finance Manager, as interim director, effective immediately, and says he has worked for the system for just under 16 years. The announcement's date is not shown on the page; reporting places the appointment in April 2026. Board Chair Cody York said Coutcher's HR and finance background made him well suited to day-to-day operations, and described the focus as stability.
The system's announcement says the board would launch a formal national search for a permanent director in the coming weeks, and that the interim director would carry out existing board policies, support branch managers, help with the budget process and avoid major new initiatives. Reporting in May 2026 cited a minimum salary of $115,000 for the permanent post, and in July the board invited the public to watch its candidate interviews.
The lawsuit
On September 23, 2026, WSMV reported that Luanne James, the former director, had filed a lawsuit over her March termination. The suit alleges that the firing violated civil rights and employee discrimination protections as well as the First Amendment. WSMV's report does not name the court, does not state the relief sought, and reports that the defendants had not responded at that time.
Update, Nov. 13: The most recent item found on the lawsuit is the September 23, 2026 report, and no ruling was found. No published report of a permanent director being selected was found.






