NashVillager Podcast: Sanctuary as a custom, not a law

Why do we consider churches a protected space from law enforcement? 

There’s been a lot of consternation over the White House decision not to consider worships spaces sanctuaries from immigration raids, but our law has never said they were. Plus, the local news for August 11, 2025, and author Kevin Wilson. 

Credits:
This is a production of Nashville Public Radio
Host/producer: Nina Cardona
Editor: Miriam Kramer
Additional support: Mack Linebaugh, Tony Gonzalez, LaTonya Turner and the staff of WPLN and WNXP

What changed for houses of worship

The episode points to a White House decision about worship spaces and immigration raids. The change that drew the most attention came earlier, from the Department of Homeland Security. A memo dated January 20, 2025 rescinded the October 27, 2021 guidance, titled Guidelines for Enforcement Actions in or Near Protected Areas, which had treated houses of worship as sensitive locations. The memo did not replace it with a bright-line rule. According to the Immigration Policy Tracking Project, a January 31, 2025 ICE memorandum, Common Sense Enforcement Actions in or Near Protected Areas, still lists churches and other houses of worship as protected areas, but leaves decisions about whether, where and when to act there to field office leaders on a case-by-case basis.

Why the custom never became a law

The episode's title, Sanctuary as a custom, not a law, points to a long-standing gap. The episode's framing is that protection for churches from police and immigration action has rested on custom rather than on a statute that bars enforcement in worship spaces. The January 2025 change came through agency guidance, not a statute. The sensitive-locations policy that was rescinded applied to houses of worship, schools, playgrounds and hospitals, and required supervisor approval before operations at those sites.

How the change was challenged

Religious groups went to court soon after. A NBC News report published January 27, 2025 described a suit by several regional Quaker umbrella groups, filed in federal court in Maryland against the Department of Homeland Security. The tracker lists related complaints filed in February 2025, including the Mennonite Church USA case in the District of Columbia. In the Philadelphia Yearly Meeting case, a federal court granted a preliminary injunction on February 24, 2025 covering the plaintiffs' places of worship. In the Mennonite Church case, a preliminary injunction was denied in April 2025 for lack of likely standing. The tracker also lists a February 13, 2026 preliminary injunction in a New England Synod case. These rulings are contested and fact-specific, and they apply only to the plaintiffs named in each case.

Update, Nov. 13: The Immigration Policy Tracking Project lists later court activity, including the February 13, 2026 New England Synod injunction. Those later entries have not been confirmed against court dockets.

Author

  • Welcome to Nashvegas.com. This site was designed to help foster communication between the residents of Nashville, Tennessee. Whether you're looking for news, events, jobs, etc. you can find it all right here on Nashvegas.com.

Nashvegas.com

Welcome to Nashvegas.com. This site was designed to help foster communication between the residents of Nashville, Tennessee. Whether you're looking for news, events, jobs, etc. you can find it all right here on Nashvegas.com.

Related Articles

Back to top button