Library director fired after book dispute in Rutherford County

The decision came after a tense public meeting, where board members clashed over whether the titles should be moved to the adult section. At the center of the debate was the director’s refusal to relocate the books, a stance that drew both support and criticism from the community and officials.

The vote to fire the director

The Rutherford County Library Board voted 8-3 at a special meeting on Monday, March 30, 2026, to fire library system director Dr. Luanne James, according to NewsChannel 5. Reports from AP and local television outlets agree on the core facts of the vote.

The dispute began when the board voted in March to move children's books to the adult section of county libraries. NewsChannel 5 reported that the board's action covered 132 children's books. AP described the books as more than 100 titles with LGBTQ themes. The board said the books were inappropriate because of their themes, which it listed as LGBTQ+ themes, female empowerment, diversity, witches and social justice.

The director's position

James refused to move the books. Her statement, issued through her attorney, argued that the move violated First Amendment rights and amounted to viewpoint discrimination. She also said librarians should not be used to enforce political agendas, and that her firing was unlawful for the same reason. Her email to the board said she would not comply with the decision.

The board's reasoning

Board chair Cody York said the board has the authority and responsibility to set policy for the library system. In an earlier statement he said that a director who refuses to carry out a duly adopted board decision undermines the governance of the institution. At the meeting he declined to explain the firing further, according to NewsChannel 5.

Board member Allison Belt had urged the board to seek specialized counsel before acting. She warned that the library system's insurance might not cover damages if the board were found to have violated the law. The board later moved to hire a private employment attorney, according to the same reporting.

What is not yet known

Whether the board violated any law has not been established. Those are the claims of James and her attorney, and they have not been decided by a court. Whether the books have since been moved has not been reported.

Update, Nov. 13: No reporting of a lawsuit filed after the March 30 firing has been published. Whether one has been filed has not been confirmed beyond what was reported in late March 2026.

Author

  • Welcome to Nashvegas.com. This site was designed to help foster communication between the residents of Nashville, Tennessee. Whether you're looking for news, events, jobs, etc. you can find it all right here on Nashvegas.com.

Nashvegas.com

Welcome to Nashvegas.com. This site was designed to help foster communication between the residents of Nashville, Tennessee. Whether you're looking for news, events, jobs, etc. you can find it all right here on Nashvegas.com.

Related Articles

Back to top button